My last post, where I mentioned I had put on some pounds, may have suggested that I've ballooned back up to my obese state prior to going low carb. It's not the case as you can see in the following photo:
I have no idea how many pounds I'm up as I threw out my scale many years ago and have since gone by how my clothes fit. I don't care about numbers on the scale; they are truly meaningless and say nothing about body composition, but I'm guessing I'm up perhaps 10 to 15 pounds from my slimmest.
So, how do weight gains or stalls in losing happen on low carb? Let's go through the list:
1. Dairy - It's a common issue that few want to admit. Cheese is wonderful and gooey, heavy cream is luscious, but it's not unusual that many people are sensitive to dairy products.
2. Too many nuts - These are easy to overeat. One handful turns into many in no time. Low carb baked goods using almond flour taste fabulous, but that's a lot of nuts to have at one time!
3. Carbs are higher than you realize - Vegetables are good things, but some are lower in carbs than others. Perhaps too many tomatoes and onions, etc., in your salads or other recipes? Or perhaps you're indulging a little too often or too much in eating fruits?
4. Too many diet drinks - Artificial sweeteners can cause a stall in some, not to mention they aren't very good for you.
5. Little to no exercise - While exercise in and of itself does not cause weight loss, it can be a helpful tool to rev up your metabolism and lift your mood. If you aren't doing it you may be shooting yourself in the foot.
6. Low carb packaged/processed foods - Those low carb protein bars or shakes you love? They can stall you in a New York minute. They can be convenient, but they aren't really your friend.
7. Medical conditions/Medications - Hormonal imbalances (hypothyroidism, etc.) can be an issue, though one not quickly or easily solved. Some medications are known to cause weight gain. It's delicate balance.
8. Fat/Protein/Carbohydrate ratios are off - Here's another delicate balance. Perhaps it's not just "carb creep" that's the issue; maybe you're eating too much protein and not enough fat? (Here's a tool that can help you out: Keto Calculator).
9. Alcohol - This is a big staller! A glass of wine with dinner is nice every now and again, but several nights a week will stop any and all weight loss. Beer is never really a great idea, even the very low carb varieties, since they are grain based, and spirits, though zero carb, are metabolized first in the body making for a certain stall in fat loss.
For me, I've done a check on most of these issues. It's certainly not number 5, as my day job is very physically challenging. I'm thinking number 7 is a strong possibility, and hopefully I can address any medical conditions in the near future. Until then I plan on keeping my ratios in order, staying active, and cutting back on or cutting out possible weight gain or stall triggers.
Have I missed anything? What makes you gain or stall that you have noticed in your journey? What has helped you break a stall?
Lisa G., with guest appearance by Rocco the Dog. |
I have no idea how many pounds I'm up as I threw out my scale many years ago and have since gone by how my clothes fit. I don't care about numbers on the scale; they are truly meaningless and say nothing about body composition, but I'm guessing I'm up perhaps 10 to 15 pounds from my slimmest.
So, how do weight gains or stalls in losing happen on low carb? Let's go through the list:
1. Dairy - It's a common issue that few want to admit. Cheese is wonderful and gooey, heavy cream is luscious, but it's not unusual that many people are sensitive to dairy products.
2. Too many nuts - These are easy to overeat. One handful turns into many in no time. Low carb baked goods using almond flour taste fabulous, but that's a lot of nuts to have at one time!
3. Carbs are higher than you realize - Vegetables are good things, but some are lower in carbs than others. Perhaps too many tomatoes and onions, etc., in your salads or other recipes? Or perhaps you're indulging a little too often or too much in eating fruits?
4. Too many diet drinks - Artificial sweeteners can cause a stall in some, not to mention they aren't very good for you.
5. Little to no exercise - While exercise in and of itself does not cause weight loss, it can be a helpful tool to rev up your metabolism and lift your mood. If you aren't doing it you may be shooting yourself in the foot.
6. Low carb packaged/processed foods - Those low carb protein bars or shakes you love? They can stall you in a New York minute. They can be convenient, but they aren't really your friend.
7. Medical conditions/Medications - Hormonal imbalances (hypothyroidism, etc.) can be an issue, though one not quickly or easily solved. Some medications are known to cause weight gain. It's delicate balance.
8. Fat/Protein/Carbohydrate ratios are off - Here's another delicate balance. Perhaps it's not just "carb creep" that's the issue; maybe you're eating too much protein and not enough fat? (Here's a tool that can help you out: Keto Calculator).
9. Alcohol - This is a big staller! A glass of wine with dinner is nice every now and again, but several nights a week will stop any and all weight loss. Beer is never really a great idea, even the very low carb varieties, since they are grain based, and spirits, though zero carb, are metabolized first in the body making for a certain stall in fat loss.
For me, I've done a check on most of these issues. It's certainly not number 5, as my day job is very physically challenging. I'm thinking number 7 is a strong possibility, and hopefully I can address any medical conditions in the near future. Until then I plan on keeping my ratios in order, staying active, and cutting back on or cutting out possible weight gain or stall triggers.
Have I missed anything? What makes you gain or stall that you have noticed in your journey? What has helped you break a stall?
Rocco never stalls! |
Labels: stalls, weight gain
My stall was primarily caused by too much protein (even Volek and Phinney's chart recommendation is still too high for me); possible carb creep; and hormonal issues, mainly PCOS, which I didn't even suspect having until about 6 months ago. I began nutritional ketosis this summer and am down 20 pounds. I was stalled at the same weight for about 2 years and then gained slightly a bit more this spring. I have been eating 20 total grams of carbs, 60 grams of protein, and topping off with enough fat to keep satisfied. Diet is pretty clean since we switched to LC paleo/primal back in late August. It was pretty clean anyway but have since quit using artificial sweeteners and all vegetable oils. Hope you get it sorted out! It is quit frustrating!
ReplyDeleteIn recent years, for a lot of people, there has been a shift in the amount of alcohol consumed. I'm not saying we who low carb (or don't) are alcoholic, but this should be taken into account in your lifestyle.
ReplyDeleteDeep down I think we all know if there has been carb creep ....
BTW Like your picture, and I'm sure Rocco the dog is a great character ....
All the best Jan
Wendy, do you have the blood ketone tester, or is that absolutely necessary for monitoring nutritional ketosis? I know that what Jimmy did, I am supposing this is the same kind of thing you are doing?
ReplyDeleteI gave up vegetable oils years ago, but still occasionally have artificial sweetener.
Jan, alcohol effects me in a much stronger way since I've been low carb, so for me it's very self-limiting. I do like the occasional glass of wine, but sometimes I can't even finish that!
ReplyDeleteRocco is quite the young and rowdy dog! Half Yorkshire Terrier, half Jack Russell Terrier, and very active! I'll add a photo of his cute little face to the post, since he was a bit camera shy in the first pic. ;)
Ah Lisa Rocco looks great ...thanks
ReplyDeleteAll the best Jan
Hey Lisa! Just "discovered" your blog. You're so down-to-earth and practical. Love it. :-)
ReplyDeleteJust wanted to chime in with something I've found to be helpful -- maybe not necessarily to break a full-on *stall,* but I feel like this helps keep me (relatively) effortlessly at a lower weight: a fasted walk, first thing in the morning. If someone's schedule/lifestyle allows, I've found this to be a great thing. Coffee/tea is okay (with heavy cream/sweetener also okay), but no solid food. (Even if you feel a little bit hungry, you'll be out walking and food isn't an option at that time, so your mind stops focusing on that pretty quickly.) I go for about an hour, which might seem like a long time, but it's a great way to start the day -- even in winter. Just bundle up. No need to powerwalk, either. A normal, comfortable pace is fine. Just being upright and moving in the fresh air seems to wonders, physically *and* mentally/emotionally. I assume what it's doing is maybe pushing the ketosis a little higher and getting the body burning fat for sure first thing in the morning. The walk doesn't usually suppress my appetite, but I can tell you that by the time I'm done, any interest I have in food is all about fat & protein. Carbs are not tempting at all.